WAGNER WARE MAGNALITE 4269-P Sidney Turkey Roaster Vguc

( Brand: Wagner Ware Magnalite ), ( Model: MAGNALITE 4269-P ), ( Stove Type Compatibility: Electric, Gas ), ( Number Of Items In Set: Three-piece ), ( Shape: Oval ), ( Color: Silver ), ( Material: Aluminum, Cast Aluminum ), ( Set Includes: Lid, Roaster, Trivet ), ( Item Length: 20 Inches ), ( Item Depth: 6 In ), ( Type: Roaster ), ( Capacity: 17 Qt ), ( Features: With Lid, With Trivet, Double Handle, Flat-bottomed, Oven-safe ), ( Item Width: 12inches ), ( Country Of Origin: United States ), ( Manufacturer Part Number: 4269-P )

Review WAGNER WARE MAGNALITE Vtg Sidney Turkey Roaster Quart Vguc

The Wagner Ware Magnalite VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster, model number 4269-P, is a vintage-style, high-quality kitchen essential perfect for roasting turkeys and large birds during the holiday season or for special occasions. This roaster boasts a timeless design, reminiscent of the classic Sidney roasters from the mid-20th century.

Measuring 17 inches in length, this roaster is an excellent size for accommodating large turkeys up to 20 pounds. Its generous size also allows for the roasting of multiple chickens or smaller birds simultaneously. The Magnalite material, a proprietary aluminum alloy developed by Wagner Ware, ensures even heat distribution and retention, resulting in consistently juicy and perfectly cooked results.

The roaster features a flat, open design, allowing for easy access to the bird during cooking. The sides are high enough to contain drippings and prevent them from spilling over onto the oven floor or causing a mess. The roaster's rolled edges provide a secure and comfortable grip, making it easy to transport from the oven to the table.

The Wagner Ware Magnalite VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster is an excellent investment for those who value the tradition and quality of a classic roaster. Its durability and versatility make it an essential addition to any kitchen, ensuring that your holiday meals are not only delicious but also beautifully presented. This vintage roaster is not only functional but also a stunning piece of kitchenware that is sure to be a conversation starter at your dinner table.

Pros and Cons of buying a Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster

The Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster is a classic and durable kitchen appliance that has been a staple for many home cooks for decades. Here are some pros and cons to help you make an informed decision about purchasing this turkey roaster:

1. Durability: The Magnalite material used in this roaster is known for its strength and durability. It can withstand high temperatures and is resistant to scratches and dents.

2. Versatility: This roaster is not just for turkeys. It can be used to roast chickens, ham, or even vegetables. Its large size makes it suitable for cooking for large families or gatherings.

3. Easy to Clean: The smooth, non-porous surface of the Magnalite material makes it easy to clean. Food does not stick to it, and it can be wiped clean with a damp cloth.

4. Oven and Stovetop Safe: The roaster is safe for use in both the oven and on the stovetop. This adds to its versatility and convenience.

5. Retro Design: For those who appreciate vintage kitchenware, this roaster has a classic and timeless design that is sure to be a conversation starter.

1. Weight: The Magnalite material is heavy, which can make it difficult to move around, especially when full of food.

2. Size: The large size of the roaster may be too much for smaller households or for those who prefer to cook smaller meals.

3. Limited Color Options: The roaster is only available in silver, which may not suit everyone's kitchen decor.

4. Expensive: Compared to other roasters on the market, the Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster can be more expensive.

The Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster is a high-quality kitchen appliance that offers durability, versatility, and easy cleaning. Its retro design adds to its charm, making it a great addition to any kitchen. However, its weight and limited color options may be a deterrent for some. Additionally, its price point may be higher than some other roasters on the market. Ultimately, if you are looking for a durable and versatile roaster that can handle large meals and withstand the test of time, the Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster may be worth the investment.

If you are looking for a durable and versatile turkey roaster that can handle large meals and withstand the test of time, the Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269-P VTG Sidney Turkey Roaster is a great option to consider. Its classic design, easy cleaning, and ability to be used on the stovetop and in the oven make it a convenient and practical addition to any kitchen. However, be prepared for its higher price point and its weight, which may make it difficult to move around. If weight is a concern, you may want to consider a lighter option. If you are on a budget, there are other roasters on the market that may be more affordable.

part # 4269 prices

• $325.00-$375.00

specifications cookdinware:

• brand: Wagner Ware Magnalite
• model#: MAGNALITE 4269-P
• stove type compatibility: Electric, Gas
• number of items in set: Three-piece
• shape: Oval
• color: Silver
• material: Aluminum, Cast Aluminum
• set includes: Lid, Roaster, Trivet
• item length: 20 Inches
• item depth: 6 In
• type: Roaster
• capacity: 17 Qt
• features: With Lid, With Trivet, Double Handle, Flat-bottomed, Oven-safe
• item width: 12inches
• country of origin: United States
• manufacturer part number: 4269-P

payments cookdinWare:

• credit card: Discover
• wallet: Paypal
• other

general cookdinWare:

• Kitchen, Dining Bar > CookWare > Saucepans Stockpots
• condition: Used

seller cookdinWare:

• rating: 100.0%
• # reviews: 65

returns cookdinWare:

• policy: No Returns

shipping cookdinWare:

• service: USPS Ground Advantage
• carrier: USPS
• cost: $122.50
• type: Calculated
• class: Standard
• transit: 7-13 Days

offer cookdinWare:

• quantity: 1
• options: Ship-to-home
• availability: In Stock
• started: November 7, 2025
• sold: 0

Wagner Ware Magnalite 4269 Is Similar To:

• Wagner Ware 5469-m Vintage Magnalite Sidney 4569 M Chicken Fryer Skillet Pan With Lid (48.4% similar) $72.00–$600.00. (August 30th, 2024)
• Magnalite 4248-p Vintage Aluminum Wagner Ware Sidney O 5 Quart Dutch Oven With Lid (46.8% similar) $68.75–$149.99. (September 2nd, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 1059a Vtg Sidney O Cast Iron Skillet And Drip Drop No. 9 Cover 1069 (43.7% similar) $99.99–$138.95. (September 2nd, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 4681 Magnalite Sidney Sauce Pot Pan With Lid 1/2 P Aluminum 1.5 Qt (42.7% similar) $12.00–$35.00. (September 11th, 2024)
• Wagner 1402b X Vintage Ware Sidney Cast Iron Fryer/roaster Pan Set Nickel Plate (43.7% similar) $59.99–$85.00. (October 24th, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 4684m Vtg Sidney 4 Quart Magnalite Saucepan Double Pouring Spouts And Lid (45.9% similar) $85.00–$110.00. (November 1st, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 4267-p Magnalite Roaster 13 Quart Oval Aluminum Cookware With Trivet (51.3% similar) $210.00–$379.00. (November 4th, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 4506m Vtg Sidney Magnalite Frying Pan #4506m Double Pouring Spouts And Lid (41.8% similar) $32.30–$79.00. (November 6th, 2024)
• Wagner Ware 4248p Vintage Sidney 5 Quart Magnalite Dutch Oven / Stock Pot With Lid (37.7% similar) $54.60–$59.99. (November 6th, 2024)
• Wagner 1058t Vintage #8 Sidney-0-. Flat Bottomed. Restored Cast Iron Skillet (43.2% similar) $40.00–$75.00. (April 11th, 2025)
• Wagner Ware 4265p Vintage Magnalite Roaster Dutch Oven Aluminum Pot With Lid Usa 13 (42.6% similar) $135.99–$184.46. (July 19th, 2025)